Updated 8 October 2026
Additional observations, fitted as points
Eight L3 applications now fit the published point estimates while preserving their exact L2 restrictions. The income and fiscal mappings remain fixed within each application.
One path-construction rule
The restriction set contains the anchor, logistic shape, calibrated support, attainment limits and credential ordering where relevant. L3 preserves the exact L2 observations and adds separately reported point targets. Within each of these eight cases, W is the identity matrix; standard errors do not set fitting weights or acceptance bands.
Exact matches minimize the criterion when attainable. These eight searches each retain one best-fitting path with nonzero residuals. This is a conditional fit, not proof of unique identification or global optimality. Five other L3 applications retain exact-match path ranges.
The eight updated L3 results
| Policy | Earnings NPV | WTP | Net public cost | MVPF | Fit RMSE |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E01 Florida Student Access Grant | $13,837.52 | $11,267.50 | $1,027.25 | 10.97 | 0.01024 years |
| E05 Wisconsin Scholars Grant | $3,583.99 | $8,975.47 | $6,376.50 | 1.41 | 0.01589 years |
| E06 Kalamazoo Promise | $54,197.83 | $58,802.48 | $16,289.06 | 3.61 | 0.01245 years |
| E17 Public-college spending | $8,581.03 | $7,573.87 | $300.17 | 25.23 | 0.00111 years |
| E19 Texas community-college tuition | $13,120.84 | $10,879.96 | −$83.94 | Self-financing | 0.00388 years |
| E21 Tuition caps and freezes | −$2,985.16 | −$1,205.97 | $1,146.07 | -1.05 | 0.00214 years |
| E37 Tennessee Promise | $113,936.10 | $86,437.02 | −$14,831.39 | Self-financing | 0.35251 pp |
| E41 Cannabis legalization: education channel | −$3,421.32 | −$2,354.48 | $47.02 | -50.08 | 0.00609 years |
Amounts use each case’s registered monetary year and policy unit, so dollar levels are not cross-policy comparisons. Each row pairs WTP and net cost from the same fitted path. Self-financing means positive WTP with nonpositive net public cost. Tennessee retains its disclosed public-data income reconstruction. Cannabis values education only. RMSE includes the exact retained inputs; “pp” means percentage points.
Download results and residuals (JSON)Download all 56 residuals (CSV)
Inspect every point target
Residual = fitted value − target. Source values retain their reported precision and the paper’s stated outcome and age conversions.
E01 · Florida Student Access Grant
Units: schooling-equivalent years · Monetary price year: 2000
| Input | Target | Fitted | Residual | Role |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| source lag 1 | 0.045750 | 0.056091 | +0.010341 | Additional point |
| source lag 2 | 0.111083 | 0.105024 | -0.006060 | Additional point |
| source lag 3 | 0.160292 | 0.146835 | -0.013457 | Additional point |
| source lag 4 | 0.181917 | 0.181917 | -0.000000 | Exact L2 |
| first semester age18.5 | 0.014792 | 0.028925 | +0.014133 | Additional point |
E05 · Wisconsin Scholars Grant
Units: schooling-equivalent years · Monetary price year: 2009
| Input | Target | Fitted | Residual | Role |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| cohort1 cumulative credits | 0.037500 | 0.068428 | +0.030928 | Additional point |
| Annual credit flow 1 | 0.020833 | 0.025938 | +0.005104 | Additional point |
| Annual credit flow 2 | 0.008333 | 0.023708 | +0.015375 | Additional point |
| Annual credit flow 3 | 0.004167 | 0.018782 | +0.014615 | Additional point |
| Annual credit flow 4 | 0.016667 | 0.037330 | +0.020664 | Additional point |
| Annual credit flow 5 | 0.041667 | 0.027938 | -0.013729 | Additional point |
| Annual credit flow 6 | 0.020833 | 0.016076 | -0.004757 | Additional point |
| pooled cohorts23 cumulative credits | 0.087500 | 0.073306 | -0.014194 | Additional point |
| Retained L2 aggregate | 0.071772 | 0.071772 | -0.000000 | Exact L2 |
E06 · Kalamazoo Promise
Units: schooling-equivalent years · Monetary price year: 2012
| Input | Target | Fitted | Residual | Role |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Retained L2 aggregate | 0.273333 | 0.273333 | +0.000000 | Exact L2 |
| two year credits | 0.134833 | 0.122854 | -0.011980 | Additional point |
| three year credits | 0.179542 | 0.197463 | +0.017922 | Additional point |
E17 · Public-college spending
Units: schooling-equivalent years · Monetary price year: 2001
| Input | Target | Fitted | Residual | Role |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Retained L2 aggregate | 0.046013 | 0.046013 | +0.000000 | Exact L2 |
| institution event t0 | 0.005041 | 0.006235 | +0.001194 | Additional point |
| institution event t1 | 0.013199 | 0.011239 | -0.001960 | Additional point |
| institution event t2 | 0.014011 | 0.013845 | -0.000166 | Additional point |
| institution event t3 | 0.013762 | 0.014693 | +0.000931 | Additional point |
E19 · Texas community-college tuition
Units: schooling-equivalent years · Monetary price year: 2012
| Input | Target | Fitted | Residual | Role |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| source age 18 | 0.031550 | 0.038841 | +0.007291 | Additional point |
| source age 19 | 0.077550 | 0.078264 | +0.000714 | Additional point |
| source age 20 | 0.112750 | 0.114291 | +0.001541 | Additional point |
| source age 21 | 0.145650 | 0.144871 | -0.000779 | Additional point |
| source age 22 | 0.172150 | 0.169401 | -0.002749 | Additional point |
| source age 23 | 0.187250 | 0.188188 | +0.000938 | Additional point |
| source age 24 | 0.209450 | 0.202006 | -0.007444 | Additional point |
| source age 26 | 0.218450 | 0.218450 | +0.000000 | Exact L2 |
E21 · Tuition caps and freezes
Units: schooling-equivalent years · Monetary price year: 2001
| Input | Target | Fitted | Residual | Role |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Retained L2 aggregate | 0.000461 | 0.000461 | +0.000000 | Exact L2 |
| institution event t0 | -0.000921 | 0.001154 | +0.002075 | Additional point |
| institution event t1 | 0.003799 | 0.000994 | -0.002805 | Additional point |
| institution event t2 | 0.001785 | -0.000126 | -0.001910 | Additional point |
| institution event t3 | -0.004202 | -0.001562 | +0.002640 | Additional point |
E37 · Tennessee Promise
Units: percentage points · Monetary price year: 2021 (reconstruction convention)
| Input | Target | Fitted | Residual | Role |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ce:C 18 19 | 3.500000 | 3.676633 | +0.176633 | Additional point |
| ce:C 19 20 | 3.200000 | 2.680707 | -0.519293 | Additional point |
| ce:C 20 21 | 2.500000 | 2.950924 | +0.450924 | Additional point |
| ce:C 21 22 | 2.700000 | 3.334780 | +0.634780 | Additional point |
| ce:C 22 23 | 2.800000 | 3.467326 | +0.667326 | Additional point |
| ce:C 23 24 | 3.500000 | 3.500000 | +0.000000 | Exact L2 |
| aa:A 18 19 | 0.200000 | 0.755623 | +0.555623 | Additional point |
| aa:A 19 20 | 1.400000 | 1.625603 | +0.225603 | Additional point |
| aa:A 20 21 | 3.100000 | 2.517882 | -0.582118 | Additional point |
| aa:A 21 22 | 2.600000 | 2.836830 | +0.236830 | Additional point |
| aa:A 22 23 | 2.900000 | 2.927979 | +0.027979 | Additional point |
| aa:A 23 24 | 4.000000 | 4.000000 | -0.000000 | Exact L2 |
| ba:B 18 19 | -0.100000 | -0.027279 | +0.072721 | Additional point |
| ba:B 19 20 | 0.100000 | -0.076261 | -0.176261 | Additional point |
| ba:B 20 21 | 0.001000 | -0.140953 | -0.141953 | Additional point |
| ba:B 21 22 | -0.200000 | 0.027986 | +0.227986 | Additional point |
| ba:B 22 23 | 1.200000 | 1.057222 | -0.142778 | Additional point |
| ba:B 23 24 | 2.700000 | 2.700000 | +0.000000 | Exact L2 |
E41 · Cannabis legalization: education channel
Units: schooling-equivalent years · Monetary price year: 2000
| Input | Target | Fitted | Residual | Role |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BA four year bridge | -0.032000 | -0.026976 | +0.005024 | Additional point |
| BA five year bridge | -0.022000 | -0.031273 | -0.009273 | Additional point |
| BA six year bridge | -0.036000 | -0.036000 | +0.000000 | Exact L2 |
Wisconsin’s semester and cumulative effects do not form an established exact adding-up identity. The original values and cohort windows are retained; residuals can reflect aggregation and model approximation.
Input uncertainty remains separate
Public-college spending, Texas tuition, tuition caps, Tennessee Promise and cannabis each refit 1,000 registered input perturbations. Tuition caps has 1,000 verified monetary fits and 998 defined MVPFs. Florida, Wisconsin and Kalamazoo lack complete joint L3 draws; no full-L3 uncertainty interval is imputed. The paper reports the inputs varied and the limits of these conditional summaries.
The interactive explorer continues to illustrate Chapter 3’s exact, generated observations. These policy results use the source-specific observation operators and accounts documented in the paper.